| 
 
 | 
   
    |  | Training | In 
        Orbit | Gagarin | Survival 
        | Warm Fuzzies | Life in Star City/Space 
        City || Operations | Ops Leads and 
        RIOs | DOR | MCC Houston 
        | MCC Moscow |
 Training 
         With 
          the Shuttle-Mir Program, astronaut training took on many new dimensions. 
          NASAs Mir astronauts, who had previously prepared for Shuttle spaceflights 
          of up to two weeks, now spent many months in Russia preparing to spend 
          up to six months in orbiton a Russian space station, with Russian crewmates, 
          speaking the Russian language.
 The Mir astronauts trained to: ensure crew safety (including a possible 
          emergency descent in a Soyuz capsule); support Mirs systems and equipment; 
          perform workstation organization; communicate with Mission Controls 
          in both Houston and Moscow; conduct scientific research; and perform 
          station maintenance and physical exercises using Mirs onboard facilities. Meanwhile in Houston, the NASA Shuttle astronaut crews selected for 
          the Mir docking missions now trained for new tasks. These included flying 
          with Russians as crewmates, rendezvousing and docking with the Russian 
          space station, and working onboard Mir. Five Russian cosmonauts also 
          trained at NASAs Johnson Space Center to fly onboard Space Shuttles 
          as members of American Shuttle crews. This getting readythe training and preparationfor the Shuttle-Mir 
          missions required frequent travel, lengthy relocations, and innovative 
          institutional support. It also required the two space agencies to adapt 
          to each others techniques and philosophies.    For 
          the most part, the Russian and American space agencies used similar 
          training methods, but the mixes of methods differed. In general, NASA 
          required its crews to have more hands-on training and relied more on 
          "sims"the realistic simulations of spaceflight situations. 
          The Russian Space Agency also used simulations, but it did not veri-simulate 
          as many situations and activities.
    NASA's 
          Mir astronauts in Russia spent a lot of time in classroom training before 
          they took final oral examinations. (Until recently, American astronaut 
          candidates were not given formal examinations.) As NASA-3 Mir Astronaut 
          John Blaha put it, "In Russia, they do it the old-fashioned way. 
          A person takes a piece of chalk and he goes to a chalkboard, and youre 
          sitting as one student or two students, no more. That piece of chalk 
          goes to the chalkboard, and the man starts teaching you a particular 
          system in a Soyuz or on Mir. And, you take notes and you ask questions. 
          When the course is complete, the Russians have another team administer 
          an oral exam to the student."
  William C. "Charlie" Brown, cochair for the training working 
          group, said this training system works for the Russians partly because 
          they have a lower turnover in staff. Once NASA establishes a program, 
          it systematizes the training and relies more on written materials, part-task 
          trainers, and full simulations. The Russians, however, have historically 
          resisted writing things down, partly for security reasons. According 
          to Brown, "Their advantage has been [that] they keep people around 
          for 20 or 30 years, doing the same kind of thing. So, they dont have 
          that problem of turnover. But, at the same time, they dont have the 
          portability of, say, a workbookhanding it to somebody and telling them 
          to go home and study it."
 Regarding classroom-style training, Shuttle-Mir Program Manager Frank 
          Culbertson said, "The impression of a lot of our people, particularly 
          initially, was that it was not very efficientthat we could come in 
          here, clean house, and do all this in a couple of days and everybody 
          would be thoroughly trained.  "The 
          Russians, for their own reasons . . . based on practical experience, 
          didnt agree with that, [and they] still dont agree with that. They 
          still believe that you need a certain amount of this type of training 
          to be really ready to do what were asking you to do." Culbertson 
          said he received a postflight note, from NASA-6 Mir Astronaut David 
          Wolf, that said that in retrospect the Russian training methods made 
          Wolf learn the systems in a different way than he would have otherwise. 
          Wolfs note said, "It made me think about [the systems] rather 
          than just read about them, and it made me exercise the language and 
          the jargon." Understanding the Russian space jargon was crucial, 
          said Culbertson, "because youre not dealing just with the Russian 
          language versus the English language. . .. Its like when you first 
          come to NASA. I mean, how many of us understood the first lecture we 
          sat through at NASA? It was like a totally new language."
 Financial costs also factored into the differences in training techniques. 
          The American space program was much better funded than the Russian space 
          program at the time of Shuttle-Mir, and it could better afford the expensive 
          simulators.    But, 
          a big reason for the differences in training was the basic differences 
          in the missions that the two space programs were required to carry out. 
          The Americans typically trained for two-week-long Space Shuttle missions 
          on which everything had to go right the first time. Also, NASA gave 
          its Shuttle crews more operational responsibility than the Russian Space 
          Agency gave its Mir crews. Therefore, almost every activity on a Shuttle 
          mission was rehearsed, as exactly as possible, on the ground. The Russians, 
          on the other hand, trained their Mir crews for the long haul. Mission 
          Control-Moscow may have controlled many of Mirs orbital adjustments, 
          but cosmonauts had to be well-trained in the systems and in maintaining 
          the systems becauseunlike on the Space Shuttlemalfunctioning equipment 
          could not be brought down to be fixed on the ground.
    Also, 
          sometimes activities such as spacewalks became necessary after a Mir 
          crew was in orbit. For those, the cosmonauts had to do their training 
          onboard Mir.
 Another training method the Russians employed was that of putting cosmonauts 
          through weeks-long sessions in an isolation chamber to experience psychological, 
          social, and culture deprivation. No NASA Mir astronaut took part in 
          this isolation training, but NASA later incorporated this training method 
          for its International Space Station crew candidates. In sum, having to learn two systemsthe Space Shuttles and the Mirspractically 
          doubled the Mir astronauts required knowledge base. Having to train 
          in different countries, time zones, languages, and cultures made the 
          training aspect of the Shuttle-Mir Program one of the most difficult 
          jobs NASA has ever attempted. As NASA-5 Mir astronaut Mike Foale said, 
          "Flights are hard; but, believe it or not, the training is harder." Making this "hard" but effective training possible were crew 
          training working group co-chairs Aleksandr P. Aleksandrov, Charlie Brown, 
          Yuri N. Glaskov, Yuri Kargopolov, and Donald Puddy. Tommy E. Capps was 
          Johnson Space Centers Training Manager.  During 
          the Shuttle-Mir Program, nine NASA astronauts trained in Russia at the 
          Gagarin Cosmonaut Training Center. Five Russian cosmonauts (Krikalev, 
          Titov, Kondakova, Sharipov, and Ryumin) underwent training at Johnson 
          Space Center for their Shuttle flights as part of American crews. (Titov 
          flew twice.) Nine Shuttle crews took one week of training in Russia 
          for joint activities with Russian crews on Mir. The Russian primary 
          and backup crews of Mir-20 through Mir-25 underwent one week of training 
          at Johnson Space Center.
 |  
  
  
  
  
  
  
   Back to 
        
  Training 
        & Ops   TOC
 | 
   
    | _______________________________________________________________ 
| Training | In 
        Orbit | Gagarin | Survival 
        | Warm Fuzzies | Life in Star City/Space 
        City || Operations | Ops Leads and 
        RIOs | DOR | MCC Houston 
        | MCC Moscow |
 Training in Orbit 
        An astronauts training for a Mir increment was so extensive, and the 
          time to train was so limited, that NASA engineers and scientists developed 
          a training system to be used onboard the space station. The Crew On-orbit Support System (COSS) consisted of a laptop personal 
          computer with a CD-ROM drive. Compact disks held training lessons, experiment 
          instructions, and background information as well as psychological support 
          materials such as greetings from family members. In many cases, ground 
          team members videotaped the Mir astronauts last training sessions, 
          so that later on orbit they could see themselves asking questions and 
          operating the equipment. Shuttle-Mir Mission Scientist John Uri called 
          the system "a perfect refresher." An operations lead in Mission Control-Moscow might say to the Mir astronaut, 
          "Okay, on Tuesday youre going to do the experiment, but on Monday, 
          we want you to watch the video (on the CD-ROM), so by the time you get 
          to the experiment, you know what youre doing." | 
   
    | _______________________________________________________________ 
| Training | In 
        Orbit | Gagarin | Survival 
        | Warm Fuzzies | Life in Star City/Space 
        City || Operations | Ops Leads and 
        RIOs | DOR | MCC Houston 
        | MCC Moscow |
 Gagarin Cosmonaut Training Center 
         NASAs 
          Mir astronauts trained for their Shuttle-Mir missions mainly at the 
          Gagarin Cosmonaut Training Center at Star City, about 30 kilometers 
          north of Moscow.
 Like NASAs astronaut training center at Johnson Space Center in Houston, 
          Texas, the Gagarin Cosmonaut Training Center offers high-tech training 
          facilities. These include: integrated simulators for the Soyuz spacecraft 
          and the Mir space station; a 5,000-cubic-meter water tank for spacewalking 
          training; an IL-76MDK aircraft "flying laboratory" for simulating 
          microgravity; and large (TsF-18) and small (TsF-7) centrifuges for simulating 
          g-loads during launch. The Center also conducts survival training for many possible landing 
          situations, including mountains, woodlands, marshes, deserts, the Arctic, 
          and open water. Russian cosmonauts have experienced several rough Soyuz 
          landings. For example, cosmonauts Belyayev and Leonov landed on permafrost 
          in 1965; and Lazarev, Zudov, and Rozhdestvensky splashed down in Lake 
          Tengiz in 1976. All seven Shuttle-Mir astronauts returned to Earth onboard 
          Space Shuttles, but an emergency evacuation of Mir in a Soyuz was always 
          a possibility. The Soviet decision to construct a cosmonaut training center was made 
          on January 11, 1960. In 1968, it was named for Yuri Gagarin, the first 
          human in space. On May 15, 1995, after the collapse of the Soviet Union, 
          the Russian government established the Russian State Scientific Research 
          Center of Cosmonaut Training, also named after Yuri Gagarin. It was 
          placed under the authorities of the Russian Ministry of Defense (Air 
          Force) and the new Russian Space Agency. Beyond training Soviet and 
          Russian cosmonauts, the Gagarin Cosmonaut Training Center had trained 
          by April 1, 1996 25 international crews, including 24 astronauts from 
          17 countries. | 
   
    | _______________________________________________________________ 
| Training | In 
        Orbit | Gagarin | Survival 
        | Warm Fuzzies | Life in Star City/Space 
        City || Operations | Ops Leads and 
        RIOs | DOR | MCC Houston 
        | MCC Moscow |
 Survival Training 
         NASAs 
          Mir astronauts underwent survival training in Russia to learn how to 
          deal with emergency Soyuz capsule landings, both on land and in water.
 Land survival training took place during winter in the forest near 
          Star City. Crews practiced getting out of a capsule, still hot from 
          reentry, and then keeping warm in subfreezing temperatures. Water survival 
          training took place in the Black Sea. For a cold-water landing, the 
          crews had to get out of their reentry suits before they put on four 
          layers of arctic winter survival clothing, followed by an orange drysuit. 
          For a warm-water landing, crewmembers stayed in their reentry suits, 
          put on life jackets, and gathered all their survival gear. According to NASA-5 Mir Astronaut Mike Foale, "This is all done 
          with the hatch closed, in extremely close quarters, so a significant 
          heat load builds up, added to by the continuous bobbing about in the 
          waves. It takes one to two hours to get ready, then quickly open the 
          hatch, and then jump out with the proper equipment. "Jumping out is the key to the exercise. The capsule does not 
          float level, and there is great danger of the first person rocking the 
          capsule so that water comes in through the top and sinks the others. 
          We were told to simply fall, and not [to] push off in any way with our 
          legs." Finally, after the launching of signal flares, the crew was picked 
          up. Foale said, "I had five liters or more of water in my suit 
          by this time." Reassuringly, "the training suits leak worse 
          than real ones."  Bonnie Dunbar said the land survival training was perhaps "the 
          most comfortable thing" that she had done in her training for Mir. 
          That was because "I grew up in the Northwest. My dad was a World 
          War II Marine, and he used to teach us survival. You know, the snows 
          on the ground, youre out with your horse. Youre checking the fence 
          and it gets foggy and you lose your way. How do you survive? I learned 
          survival from the time I was a kid. So, being out there in the woods 
          in the snow and taking care of the fire actually was kind of fun." 
          Russian trainers were always nearby for safety. | 
   
    | _______________________________________________________________ 
| Training | In 
        Orbit | Gagarin | Survival 
        | Warm Fuzzies | Life in Star City/Space 
        City || Operations | Ops Leads and 
        RIOs | DOR | MCC Houston 
        | MCC Moscow |
 "Warm Fuzzies": Training Cosmonauts for the Space Shuttle 
         Lisa 
          Reed, Training Lead at Johnson Space Center, was partly responsible 
          for the training of Russian cosmonauts who were scheduled to fly on 
          Space Shuttles. Later, Reed talked about working with Sergei Krikalev 
          and Vladimir Titov, and dealing with the peculiarities of the American 
          language.
 "In order to get those guys trained by February [1994], so they 
          could join the rest of the [STS-60] crew in the training flow . . . 
          we instructors spent eight hours a day with them. For example, Monday 
          on their schedule would be electrical power day. I would start in the 
          morning with a briefing for two hours. Id have a [Russian language] 
          translator sitting with me, and Sergei and Vlodya [Titov] sitting across 
          from me. "It was difficult, because [we had] to pause with the translators. 
          If it took an hour to teach it to an American, it took three hours" 
          with the Russians "because we had to translate everything. "I actually felt sorry for those guys, because they were getting 
          a lot. It must have been like drinking from a fire hose for them because 
          . . . every day, it was a different system. But, they rose to the task 
          and did very well." The trainers also ran into problems with slang. According to Reed, 
          "We Americans like our slang. We dont realize we use it as much 
          as we do. So, [the Russians] would stop us.  I remember one day, I was teaching Sergei about the hydraulic system. "I was explaining to him that . . . [the Shuttle crew] will start 
          one [hydraulic system] prior to the deorbit burn . . . basically just 
          to make everybody feel good that you have one running. The term that 
          all the instructors here use [for this reassurance] is warm fuzzy. "I remember [Krikalev] stopped, and he looked at me, and he goes, 
          What is this warm fuzzy? "And, I couldnt explain it to him because I tried to separate 
          the words. Warm, to him, was like near hot. Then, [there was] fuzzy. 
          We got off into talking about teddy bears and fur, and it just degraded 
          from there. "I dont think that he ever quite understood what a warm fuzzy 
          was." | 
   
    | _______________________________________________________________ 
| Training | In 
        Orbit | Gagarin | Survival 
        | Warm Fuzzies | Life in Star City/Space 
        City || Operations | Ops Leads and 
        RIOs | DOR | MCC Houston 
        | MCC Moscow |
 Life in Star City, Russia and "Space City," Texas 
           NASAs 
          astronauts train at the Lyndon B. Johnson Space Center (JSC) in Houston, 
          Texas. Established as the Manned Spacecraft Center in 1961 and renamed 
          in 1973, the Johnson Space Center was built on former ranch and farm 
          land just north of Clear Lake and near one of the largest petrochemical 
          complexes in the world. The area has since become a suburban center, 
          with shopping malls, office buildings, and housing developments. The 
          climate is hot and humid for much of the year.
 Russias cosmonauts live and train at a place called Star City, home 
          to the Gagarin Cosmonaut Training Center. Star City lies in a forest 
          30 miles outside of Moscow. Star City has a northern continental climate 
          with cold winters and brief, warm summers. Many Shuttle-Mir team members 
          lived or stayed in Star City during the Phase 1 Program. Several of 
          their family members joined them during their training in there. In 1960, when Star City was established, housing consisted of two 5-story 
          buildings. Now, thousands of people live and work at Star City. Many 
          NASA Shuttle-Mir team members lived in the "Prophylactory," 
          a three-floor dormitory the Soviets built for Americans during the Apollo-Soyuz 
          Test Project and that has since been used for cosmonauts who have come 
          back from a flight. NASA leases the second floor for housing and for 
          the office of the Director of Operations-Russia. NASA also built several 
          duplexes for housing. "Star City really is a little tiny city," said astronaut 
          William Readdy, who served as a Director of Operations. "Its self-contained, 
          and all the services are there. And, there are several generations [of 
          Russians] there . . . the original cosmonauts and their trainers, and 
          then . . . kids and grandkids and grandparents," all living in 
          the self-contained town. Mike Barratt, a NASA Flight Surgeon during Shuttle-Mir, said, "Its 
          a very historical place. . .. Star City has always been kind of . . 
          . the forbidden city or the hidden city. It wasnt on any maps. 
          . .. It was a secret cosmonaut training base. Of course, everyone knew 
          where it was, but it was considered a closed and secure city." 
          Barratt said that, early in the program in 1994, Star City was a "little 
          overwhelming" to the Americans who had just arrived. "There 
          were only four or five of us English speakers and an awful lot of themRussian 
          speakers. I think we were all looking at each other with a certain amount 
          of curiosity, maybe suspicion. But, that gave way relatively quickly. 
          . .. It was a very short time later that it became a very comfortable 
          placea second home, really. . . . Star City is a very friendly place 
          and a very beautiful placepeaceful, quiet, forests, trees, fresh air." Early in the program, and largely due to the problems Russia faced 
          after the fall of the Soviet Union, many aspects of life and work at 
          Star City did not match those of Houston. Communications and customs were big problems. Some foods were only 
          available in the little store inside the U.S. Embassy in Moscow. But, 
          according to NASA-5 Mir Astronaut Mike Foale, "Things got steadily 
          better. In fact, Russia has changed incredibly in terms of services. 
          . . . Moscow is unrecognizable compared to the way it was" in 1996. Often, work took up almost all of the Shuttle-Mir team members time. 
          After his Mir flight, NASA-3 Mir Astronaut John Blaha recalled looking 
          at albums of photos of Russia that his wife, Brenda, had put together. 
          He remembered he told her, "Brenda, these are really great books, 
          but thats not what I saw of Russia." Blaha said that what he remembered 
          was "a desk in a little room in my apartment, where I was studying 
          my lesson material." Blaha went on to describe a typical workday at Star City. "I would 
          get up in the morning, sometimes at four-thirty . . . to study for my 
          classes that day. Somewhere around [eight oclock] . . . Brenda would 
          walk into my little study room. She would say, Your breakfast is ready. 
          . . . Id eat breakfast with her. . .. Then, I would go off to class. 
          . .. There was a one-hour lunch break, [then] class from two to four 
          [oclock and] from four to six [oclock]. It was like going to college. 
          The instructors used a blackboard and a piece of chalk. At six oclock, 
          I would arrive home. Id walk in, Id relax a little bit, [then] Id 
          start studying until ten-thirty, 11 oclock at night. Somewhere in between, 
          Brenda would say, John, dinners ready. And, wed go and sit down, 
          and wed eat dinner together and talk." Shuttle-Mir cosmonauts Vladimir Titov and Sergei Krikalevwith their 
          familiesspent considerable time living and training at the Johnson 
          Space Center in Houston, Texas. They also had experiences adapting to 
          a different culture. But, for them, early in the program the changes 
          were in the other directionfrom a situation of fewer material goods 
          to more. In 1998, Titov looked back on the "difficult time" 
          of the early 90s in Russia. He said, "Moscow was not very comfortable, 
          and when we arrived [in] Houston, here was another life, another style, 
          and other stores. And, everything was for us like a little bit new." Travis Brice, a key Shuttle-Mir Program Manager, recalled that, in 
          late 1992, the Krikalevs and Titovs wanted to go to Tampa, Florida, 
          to visit French astronaut Jean-Loup Chrétien. Brice suggested 
          driving. "We can do that?" the Russians asked. "Sure," Brice said, "You can do it. . . . You just get 
          in your car and you go down to I-10 and turn right." "We can do that?" "Yes." "We wont get arrested?" "No. Just go. Obey the speed limits . . . and youll probably 
          be okay." The Russians asked, "How about gasoline?" "Plenty of gas stations along the way," Brice told them. 
          "Just watch your tank and dont get low. Keep your car full of 
          gas and just go." | 
   
    | _______________________________________________________________ 
       
| Training | In 
        Orbit | Gagarin | Survival 
        | Warm Fuzzies | Life in Star City/Space 
        City || Operations | Ops Leads and 
        RIOs | DOR | MCC Houston 
        | MCC Moscow |
 Operations - A Tale of Two Systems 
         "Operations," 
          in essence, means managing a spaceflight while it is taking place. Originally, 
          the Space Shuttle and the Mir were not compatible vehicles because they 
          were developed independently for different purposes. During Shuttle-Mir, 
          the differences required many adaptations to allow the joint operation 
          of the docked vehicles and to support an astronaut on a long-duration 
          mission.
 The joint missions required coordination between two control centers 
          thousands of miles apart from each other, in different time zones, and 
          with different native languages.  Communications links, processes, and procedures were developed to exchange 
          information between control teams, coordinate decisions, and accommodate 
          changes. An American, who served as a Russian Interface Officer (RIO) 
          in Houston, and a Russian equivalent, the "PRP," in Moscow, 
          acted as communicators between the NASA Flight Director at Mission Control 
          Center-Houston and the Russian Flight Director at Mission Control Center-Moscow. During docked operations, neither Mission Control Center was fully 
          in charge of joint activities. The Mission Control Center-Moscow had 
          authority for Mir. The Mission Control Center-Houston was responsible 
          for the Space Shuttle. Similarly, the Shuttle commander was responsible 
          for the Shuttle and its crew, and the Mir commander was responsible 
          for the Mir and its crew. "Joint Flight Rules," developed before each Shuttle-Mir mission, 
          detailed both planned operations and practical responses to unusual 
          situations. These rules minimized the need for quick decisions and ensured 
          that each course of action had been reviewed and agreed to, both by 
          NASA and the Russian Space Agency. The differences between a typical Space Shuttle mission and a Mir expedition 
          are noteworthy. For a typical Shuttle mission, Mission Control Center-Houston 
          runs operations and directs practically every activity onboard the spacecraft. 
          The short duration of a Shuttle mission requires that the crews time 
          be closely scripted and monitored to get everything done. Further, with 
          the aid of tracking satellites, Mission Control Center-Houston enjoys 
          nearly constant contact with its Space Shuttles, so up-to-the-minute 
          instructions can be radioed to the crew. With much less voice communications than Houston has, Mission Control 
          Center-Moscow typically uplinked a written flight plan to the Mir crew 
          each day. This plan outlined a single day to five days in the future, 
          and it gave a high degree of crew autonomy in the actual scheduling 
          of activities. Furthermore, the long duration of a Mir expedition required 
          more routine and normalcy for both its crews and its controllers. A 
          "crew day" on Mir started at 8 a.m. Moscow time and extended 
          to 11 p.m., allowing nine hours off for personal time and sleep. Usually, 
          Mir crews worked five days per week and took two days off. During their 
          days off, crewmembers were required only to do light housekeeping and 
          perform their physical exercises, which took about two hours each day. 
          Mission Control Center-Moscow personnel likewise had more regular hours. 
          According to Flight Director Phil Engelauf, this gave people the feeling 
          "that you get up in the morning and you have some time to yourself. 
          You have a workday. Then youre off in the evening, and you have your 
          weekends to yourself." Of course, hardware failures and other contingencies 
          frequently changed the routines and lengths of days worked, both for 
          the crews onboard Mir and for the operations people on the ground. During the course of Shuttle-Mir, NASA adapted its onboard astronaut 
          operationsespecially those of the science programto be more flexible, 
          like the Russians. For example, according to the Shuttle-Mir Program 
          Deputy Manager James Van Laak, "[We] might tell the crewmember, 
          Today wed like you to accomplish the following three things. Then, 
          if the astronaut began the first procedure and the hardware did not 
          work well, he or she could postpone it and start a second project until 
          the next communications pass came up. After discussing the situation 
          with Mission Control, the astronaut might then go back to the second 
          experiment because it might take Mission Control some time to figure 
          out what to do next. Then, at the following communications pass, Mission 
          Control would uplink a solution to the problem, and the astronaut might 
          go back to the first experiment." Flight Director Robert Castle said that, with Mir operations, "Things 
          are a little slower-paced." He gave as an example an episode when 
          an Elektron oxygen generator malfunctioned. "[The Americans] said, 
          Okay, youre going to bring in a bunch of people to go work on this, 
          right? [The Russians] said, Well, were really not going to bring 
          anybody in. Well start working on [the malfunction] Monday. And, this 
          was a Friday afternoon. Then our own environmental people said, With 
          the current pressure of oxygen in the Mir, and the volume of the Mir, 
          and the number of people onboard [the Mir], it will take 10 days to 
          breathe the oxygen down. . . . Well, I can see why you might want to 
          just take the weekend off, let people come in fresh, and work on it 
          Monday, because youve still got a lot of time to work on itwhereas 
          in the Shuttle Program, 10 days is an entire mission." Except in rapidly evolving situations, controllers could assume that 
          Mir would "be there in the morning." So, they could take the 
          time needed to do things, in the best way, overall. | 
   
    | _______________________________________________________________ 
| Training | In 
        Orbit | Gagarin | Survival 
        | Warm Fuzzies | Life in Star City/Space 
        City || Operations | Ops Leads and 
        RIOs | DOR | MCC Houston 
        | MCC Moscow |
 Operations Leads and Russian Interface Officers 
        Early on, NASA managers realized that a Flight Surgeon alone could 
          not handle all the communications with the astronaut onboard Mir. So, 
          they created the position of Operations Leador "Ops Lead"to 
          act both as a CAPCOM [capsule communicator] with the Mir astronaut and 
          as the leader of a NASA operations team in Russia. The goal, according 
          to Program Manager Frank Culbertson, was for the Mir astronaut, the 
          Flight Surgeon, and the Ops Lead to become "a good, solid team 
          and stick together through training, know the mission very well, and 
          be able to execute it together." Jeffery Cardenas, the Ops Lead for Norm Thagards Mir increment, later 
          said that he typically arrived at Mission Control Center-Moscow about 
          an hour before the first communications pass, or "com pass," 
          with Mir. He talked to the Russian shift flight directors for that day, 
          asked them what had happened onboard Mir overnight, and checked updates 
          on the Mir systems, especially anything that would affect events for 
          that day. He then read over the prepared script of what he was planning 
          to say because he would have, at most, 10 minutes of communications 
          time. When the com pass with Mir occurred, Cardenas would go over the 
          script with Norm Thagard onboard Mir, "trying to give him a thumbnail 
          sketch of whats coming up on the day." For the rest of the day, 
          Cardenas kept current on Thagards activities and prepared for com passes 
          three or four days in the future. Ops Leads during Shuttle-Mir included Cardenas, Christine Chiodo, Scott 
          Gahring, William Gerstenmaier, Isaac "Cassi" Moore, Patricia 
          "Patti" Moore, Anthony Sang, and Keith Zimmerman. Other unique Mission Control positions created for the Shuttle-Mir 
          Program were NASAs Russian Interface Officer (RIO) at Mission Control 
          Center-Houston and its Russian Space Agency equivalentthe PRPat Mission 
          Control Center-Moscow. According to Flight Director Phil Engelauf, the 
          Russian Interface Officer served as the focal point for communications, 
          or facilitator for communications, between the two control centers. 
          The Russian Interface Officer managed fax traffic back and forth to 
          the control centers as well as the voice conversations. Flight directors 
          and specialists still communicated directly, but, as RIO Sally Davis 
          said, "As far as marching down the road of executing the mission, 
          you need somebody thats going to keep each control center in sync, 
          because you can go off [in] 40 directions with everybody [involved doing 
          their own tasks]. You have that problem anyway with one flight control 
          team. So, with two [control centers operating], you needed, I guess 
          youd call it, a sync pulse. . .[to keep] the control teams in line." | 
  
    | _______________________________________________________________ 
| Training | In 
        Orbit | Gagarin | Survival 
        | Warm Fuzzies | Life in Star City/Space 
        City || Operations | Ops Leads and 
        RIOs | DOR | MCC Houston 
        | MCC Moscow |
 Director of Operations - Russia 
         In 
          early 1994, the Shuttle-Mir Program created its Director of Operations-Russia 
          position and named astronaut Ken Cameron as the first Director of Operations. 
          Cameron accompanied astronauts Norm Thagard and Bonnie Dunbar to Russia 
          to manage NASAs operations at Star City and at the Russian control 
          center at Kaliningrad.
 The Director of Operations responsibilities comprised a huge task, 
          including supervising NASA astronaut training at Star City; developing 
          Mir rendezvous training materials for Shuttle crewmembers; coordinating 
          training for scientific experimenters; and establishing and maintaining 
          operations, including procedures to support joint flight operations 
          between NASA and the Russian Space Agency. In practice, the Director 
          of Operations personally handled many problems that arose in Star City. 
          Astronauts who served in that position for about six months each included: 
          Cameron, William Readdy, Ronald Sega, Michael Baker, Charles Precourt, 
          Wendy Lawrence, Michael Lopez-Alegria, Brent Jett, and James Halsell. William Readdy later talked about the early Director of Operations 
          experiences. He said, "The objective was to prepare the ground 
          and make sure that the two initial crewmembers that were over there, 
          Norm Thagard and Bonnie Dunbar, got the support they neededbasically 
          from soup to nuts." That meant everything "from everyday living 
          accommodations all the way through all the technical and professional 
          training, and all the travel and support and everything. Star City is 
          not inside Moscow. Depending on the roads and the weather, it can be 
          a couple of hours outside of Moscow, and so the logistics are daunting. "But, the idea was to support them. Of course, that means also 
          supporting the trainers and experimenters and all the other NASA folks 
          that kind of go along with that." As NASAs organization built up in Russia, the Director of Operations 
          duties evolved to become more managerial and less "Jack-of-all-trades." | 
   
    | _______________________________________________________________ 
| Training | In 
        Orbit | Gagarin | Survival 
        | Warm Fuzzies | Life in Star City/Space 
        City || Operations | Ops Leads and 
        RIOs | DOR | MCC Houston 
        | MCC Moscow |
 Mission Control Center - Houston 
         At 
          the moment the Shuttles two solid rocket boosters ignite, vehicle responsibility 
          transfers from the Kennedy Space Center launch team to Johnson Space 
          Centers Mission Control Center, where a team of experienced flight 
          controllers works in shifts to monitor and direct the operations of 
          the Space Shuttle.
 Flight Director (FLIGHT)Has overall responsibility for the conduct of the mission.
 Spacecraft Communicator (CAPCOM) By tradition an astronaut; responsible for all voice contact with the 
          flight crew.
 Flight Activities Officer (FAO) Responsible for procedures and crew timelines; provides expertise on 
          flight documentation and checklists; prepares messages and maintains 
          all teleprinter and/or Text and Graphics System traffic to the vehicle.
 Integrated Communications Officer (INCO) Responsible for all Orbiter data, voice, and video communications systems; 
          monitors the telemetry link between the vehicle and the ground; oversees 
          the uplink command and control processes.
 Flight Dynamics Officer (FDO)Responsible for monitoring vehicle performance during the powered flight 
          phase and assessing abort modes; calculating orbital maneuvers and resulting 
          trajectories; monitoring vehicle flight profile and energy levels during 
          reentry.
 Trajectory Officer (TRAJECTORY)Aids the FDO during dynamic flight phases; responsible for maintaining 
          the trajectory processors in Mission Control and for trajectory inputs 
          made to the Mission Operations Computer.
 Guidance, Navigation, & Control Systems Engineer (GNC)Responsible for all inertial navigational systems hardware such as star 
          trackers, radar altimeters, and the inertial measurement units; monitors 
          radio navigation and digital autopilot hardware systems.
 Guidance & Procedures Officer (GPO)Responsible for the onboard navigation software and for maintaining 
          the Orbiters navigation state, known as the state vector; monitors 
          crew vehicle control during ascent, entry, or rendezvous.
 Rendezvous Guidance & Procedures Officer (RENDEZVOUS)Monitors onboard navigation of the Orbiter during rendezvous and proximity 
          operations.
 Environmental Engineer & Consumables Manager (EECOM)Responsible for all life support systems, cabin pressure, thermal control, 
          and supply and wastewater management; manages consumables such as oxygen 
          and hydrogen.
 Electrical Generation & Illumination Officer (EGIL)Responsible for power management, fuel cell operation, vehicle lighting, 
          and the master caution and warning system.
 Payloads Officer (PAYLOADS)Coordinates all payload activities; serves as principal interface with 
          remote payload operations facilities.
 Data Processing Systems Engineer (DPS)Responsible for all onboard mass memory and data processing hardware; 
          monitors primary and backup flight software systems; manages operating 
          routines and multi-computer configurations.
 Propulsion Engineer (PROP)Manages the reaction control and orbital maneuvering thrusters during 
          all phases of flight; monitors fuel usage and storage tank status; calculates 
          optimal sequences for thruster firings.
 Booster Systems Engineer (BOOSTER)Monitors main engine and solid rocket booster performance during ascent 
          phase.
 Ground Controller (GC)Coordinates operation of ground stations and other elements of worldwide 
          space tracking and data network; responsible for Mission Control computer 
          support and displays.
 Maintenance, Mechanical, Arm, & Crew Systems (MMACS)Monitors auxiliary power units and hydraulic systems; manages payload 
          bay and vent door operations; handles in-flight maintenance planning; 
          oversees Orbiter structure, tiles, blankets, etc.
 Extravehicular Activities (EVA)Monitors and coordinates spacewalks, including extravehicular activity 
          suit and hardware performance.
 Russian Interface Officer (RIO)Acts as the communicator between the NASA Flight Director in the Mission 
          Control Center in Houston and the Russian Flight Director at the Russian 
          Mission Control Center in Kaliningrad; coordinates joint activities 
          between the Shuttle and the Mir; implements joint decisions made by 
          the two flight directors.
 Payload Deployment & Retrieval Systems (PDRS)Monitors and coordinates operation of the remote manipulator system.
 Flight Surgeon (SURGEON)Monitors health of flight crew; provides procedures and guidance on 
          all health-related matters.
 Public Affairs Officer (PAO)Provides the media and public with explanations of mission events during 
          all phases of flight.
  Read 
          more about NASA's Public Affairs Office
 | 
   
    | _______________________________________________________________ 
| Training | In 
        Orbit | Gagarin | Survival 
        | Warm Fuzzies | Life in Star City/Space 
        City || Operations | Ops Leads and 
        RIOs | DOR | MCC Houston 
        | MCC Moscow |
 Mission Control Center - Moscow 
         During 
          Shuttle-Mir, the Russian Space Agency had three control rooms in a single 
          complex in Kaliningrad, near Moscow. Mission Control Center-Moscow could 
          process data from as many as ten spacecraft, although each control room 
          was dedicated to a single program: one to Mir; one to Soyuz; and one 
          to the now discontinued Russian space shuttle, Buran.
 Flight control personnel were organized into teams, similar to NASAs 
          system at the Mission Control Center-Houston. The Flight Director provided 
          policy guidance and communicated with the mission management team. The 
          Flight Shift Director was responsible for real-time decisions, within 
          a set of flight rules. The Mission Deputy Shift Manager was responsible 
          for the control rooms consoles, computers, and peripherals. The Mission 
          Deputy Shift Manager for Ground Control was responsible for communications. 
          The Mission Deputy Shift Manager for Crew Training was similar to NASAs 
          "CAPCOM," or capsule communicator. Generally, this person 
          had served as the Mir crews lead trainer. | 
  
   
    | | TOC 
        | Site Map | Photo Gallery 
        | Video Gallery 
        | Diagrams 
        | Welcome | Search 
        | |