NASA ENGINEERING NETWORK
Follow this link to skip to the main content
+ Contact LLIS
Go
ABOUT NASALATEST NEWSMULTIMEDIAMISSIONSMyNASAWORK FOR NASA

+ NASA Home
FIND ENGINEERING RESOURCES BY
LLIS HOME
NASA CENTERS
MISSION DIRECTORATE
TOPICS
BY YEAR


Public Lessons Learned Entry: 0568

Lesson Info:

  • Lesson Number: 0568
  • Lesson Date: 1997-08-28
  • Submitting Organization: JPL
  • Submitted by: K. Clark/D. Oberhettinger

Subject:

Battery "Popping" During ATLO (Assembly Test and Launch Operations) Due to Horizontal Mounting

Abstract:

During Mars Global Surveyor system test, it was discovered that horizontally mounted nickel-hydrogen battery cells are subject to electrolyte “pooling” in a 1 g. environment. This can damage the cells; high charge rates (and temperatures) increase the likelihood of damage. Some measures to prevent battery popping (rapid oxygen-hydrogen recombination under fast charge conditions) are recommended for nickel-hydrogen batteries during any ground phase.

Description of Driving Event:

Mars Global Surveyor (MGS) carries two nickel-hydrogen (NiH2) battery assemblies: one mounted to the +Y and one to the -Y propulsion module. Each assembly consists of eight 20Ahr NiH2 common pressure vessels (CPVs) in a honeycomb composite enclosure mounted on an aluminum baseplate. During MGS system test, shortly after installation of the batteries on the spacecraft, an intermittent "popping" or "snapping" sound issued from both batteries. This noise was most likely caused by oxygen-hydrogen (H2/O2) recombination in the battery under the fast charge rate conditions normally present throughout the charge cycle.

H2/O2 recombination is a natural chemical process which occurs mostly during the late charge and early discharge stages of NiH2 battery operation. Audible popping occurs during H2/O2 recombination when a large enough oxygen bubble is allowed to form on an electrode plate inside the cell stack before it can recombine with hydrogen. When this bubble finally does recombine, a popping sound results. Such popping may induce significant damage to cell plates and may reduce battery cycle life.

This phenomenon was exacerbated by the MGS practice of mounting and testing the battery on its side (i.e., horizontally) in a 1 g. environment. Instead of remaining fully contained within the porous electrodes, a small amount of the liquid electrolyte was drawn by the force of gravity to the bottom of the horizontal CPV. The liquid pressure from this "pooling" of electrolyte promoted the formation of oxygen bubbles large enough to recombine violently. Such pooling cannot occur in a zero g. environment.

Use of the flight batteries was judged to represent a low risk to MGS mission success. X-ray inspection showed that the popping had caused some deformation of the cell plates. However, charge retention testing showed no degradation in battery performance, and the item features a heritage design and robust capacity.

refer to [D] description[D]
Figure 1. NiH2 CPV Positioned Vertically
(only the upper of two stack sets is shown)

Additional Keyword(s): Battery Charging

Reference(s):

  • Problem/Failure Report No. B0M9XU
  • Walker, S., "Battery Noise Anomaly Close-Out Engineering Analysis," September 26, 1996

Lesson(s) Learned:

A nickel-hydrogen battery design where the cells are mounted on their sides (i.e., horizontally), instead of in the vertical position shown in Figure 1, increases the potential for electrolyte "pooling" in a 1 g. environment and for possible damage to cells. High charge rates (and temperatures) increase the likelihood of battery popping.

Recommendation(s):

For nickel-hydrogen batteries, take precautions against battery popping during any ground phase:

  1. Reduce the charge rate as the batteries approach full charge.
  2. To minimize the likelihood of pooling, ensure that battery cells contain no excess electrolyte.
  3. Mount batteries to minimize electrolyte pooling in a 1 g. environment.

Evidence of Recurrence Control Effectiveness:

N/A

Documents Related to Lesson:

N/A

Mission Directorate(s):

N/A

Additional Key Phrase(s):

  • Energy
  • Hardware

Additional Info:

    Approval Info:

    • Approval Date: 1997-10-10
    • Approval Name: Carol Dumain
    • Approval Organization: 125-204
    • Approval Phone Number: 818-354-8242


    FirstGov - Your First Click to the US Government
    + 2004 Vision for Space Exploration
    + FY 2005 Budget Request
    + 2003 Strategic Plan
    + Freedom of Information Act
    + The President's Management Agenda
    + FY 2003 Agency Performance and Accountability Report
    + NASA Privacy Statement, Disclaimer,
    and Accessibility Certification

    + Freedom to Manage
    NASA
    Curator:Manson Yew
    NASA Official: Gregory Robinson
    + Contact LLIS