Flight Research Hits the Mark
July 31, 2006
Ordinarily, Dryden's expertise is called upon to help engineers avoid
burying a flight research vehicle in the desert floor. But Sandia
National Laboratories researchers in New Mexico came to Dryden to tap
the center's expertise in order to do precisely that: "plant" their
dart-like flight research vehicle.
Image above: Tony Frackowiak, standing, left, and Tyler Beiter set up the
mothership and its underbelly passenger, the Sandia Dart research
vehicle while Jose Ruiz, left, and Victor Linn make final
preparations in the ground cockpit, to which control of the aircraft
will shift during its climb to mission altitude.
NASA Photo by Tom Tschida
Dryden technicians integrated the Sandia Darts onto the center's
utility vehicle aircraft and after several modifications, air
launched the Darts from about 3,000 feet in an attempt to
characterize the Darts' aerodynamics. The goal of the Sandia research
project was to demonstrate the aerodynamic stability and flight
performance of the Dart vehicle and embed it in the ground.
Dryden researchers integrated the Sandia-designed drop mechanism on
the utility aircraft's underside and were tasked with devising a
method of air launching the Darts accurately from a specified
position as well as ensuring that they fell to the ground in a place
from which they could then be retrieved. Among the challenges was
getting the vehicle to embed at or near the ground surface in a
variety of soils, said Steve Jacobson, Dryden's chief engineer for
the Dart project.
The drop from 3,000 feet required the resolution of another challenge
- a projectile as small as the Dart is difficult to see at 3,000 feet
above ground level, or about 5,270 feet above sea level. In the past,
aircraft released from the center's utility vehicle were launched at
Image above: Mark Howard takes a measurement of how deeply the Dart research
vehicle planted itself following an air launch from the mothership.
NASA Photo by Tom Tschida
"We had to put an autopilot on board to control our utility airplane
because it flies so high that the pilot would have a difficult time
controlling it," Jacobson explained.
Dryden Model Shop designer Tony Frackowiak said the integration of
the equipment wasn't the difficult part. The utility model was
designed for missions like air launching the 28-pound, 30-inch-long
Dart, and integrating the autopilot was not hard. Mounting the four
cameras on the aircraft, however, was a different story.
One video camera was added to each wingtip, one "chin" camera near
the front of the aircraft to capture video of the Dart falling away
and one at the tail. The camera work was for Dryden's benefit and it
added a new capability for future flight experiments.
Additionally, Frackowiak said, completing simulations of how the
hardware would work in the integrated systems and deriving the
mathematical parameters, or gains, for the autopilot were challenging.
Once the aircraft was ready and the 14 Dryden and five Sandia
Laboratories personnel had completed preparations, it was time to
fly. As is often the case with flight research, not everything went
"We became involved because we know how to fly airplanes and we know
how to drop things off of airplanes," Jacobson said. "Sandia needed
our help with the drop operations, providing the UAV and the
infrastructure to support its flight. A primary objective of the test
was (that) they wanted to be able to find it (after it came to rest
on the ground). The very top of the Dart is the only thing that is
supposed to be visible. In fact, the very first time we dropped it,
it wasn't easy to find."
But researchers had a good idea of where to look.
"We knew where it was supposed to be but winds were pushing it to one
side," Jacobson said. "We had people stationed at various points and
they walked line-of-sight to where they thought it would be. We knew
based on the wind that the drop article would be in an oval-shaped
area. When (researchers) walked to the same area from their position,
we were literally within five feet of it and didn't know. It wasn't
obvious to us."
A feature of autopilot was auto drop, which enabled researchers to
know the Dart's path and direction and the point at which air launch
would occur. Knowing the point of origin made finding the Dart easier
after the first time, Jacobson said.
The autopilot was an off-the-shelf product, Cloud Cap Piccolo Plus
hardware and guidance software. The autopilot used in the Sandia
Darts project also was used in another Dryden project, Michael
Allen's autonomous soaringresearch. Allen customized the autopilot so
his hand-launched, motorized, model sailplane would catch plumes of
rising air called thermals in much the same way as birds do,
validating a thermal model developed at Dryden.
Dryden's ability to operate in restricted airspace is another unique
feature of testing at the center, he added.
"Sandia wanted to show their drop article to their customer," he
said. "The day we showed it (to their customer representatives) we
had two drops and the operation was flawless. Because we had invested
so much time in understanding the systems and practiced with a 'dummy
Dart,' we had plenty of operational experience before the customer
showed up. The day the customer showed up, things went off without a
Image above: The mothership takes to the sky with a Sandia Dart research vehicle
secured beneath its fuselage. Air launch of the small Darts was
NASA Photo by Tom Tschida
Dryden's utility aircraft has a 10-foot wingspan, is nine and
one-half feet in length and weighs about 30 pounds in standard
configuration. Takeoff weight for the Dart project was 76 pounds, the
most the aircraft has carried, but Frackowiak said the aircraft
likely could carry even heavier payloads with the larger engine he
installed for the Sandia mission.
The Sandia-designed release mechanism consisted of a mounted,
four-jaw "clamshell" that opens to allow the object to air-launch on
release. It was spring-loaded with a pyrotechnic cutter to ensure the
mechanism worked as intended. The Darts also can be released manually.
Jacobson described the Darts' release from the utility vehicle as
"smooth as glass."
"We have added a unique capability to the utility vehicle that
increases the air-launch altitude from 1,000 to 3,000 feet, and it
could go higher with this autopilot. The utility vehicle worked great
and the releases were very smooth," he said.
Image above: Photo sequence assembled from mothership onboard camera footage by Tyler Beiter
The autopilot is a new capability for the utility vehicle that is
expected to have applications for future research.
"It certainly can be used for a variety of research - projects
similar to the Darts, or any test item that needs to be flown,"
Dryden also is working to develop a UAV trainer or proficiency
system, which was really (the late Dryden engineer) Dale Reed's
vision for the utility project, he added.
Frackowiak said the Dart demonstration flight also illustrated
Dryden's capability with small UAVs.
"Subscale or smaller UAVs can accomplish many research objectives at
a much lower cost and a shorter time frame," he said.